Trending

  • On-Demand Webinar: How Scientific Societies Could Engage in Public Crisis Management
  • Ramp-up Your Scientific Research With ‘The Research Lab Toolkit’
  • Enago’s Global Survey on Research Laboratories
  • Share Your Experiences With 2 Million+ Researchers!
  • 의학 출판—임상 사례 보고서(Clinical Case Reports) 작성

Enago Academy Enago Academy - Learn. Share. Discuss. Publish.

Enago Learn
  • h
  • Reporting Research
    • Language & Grammar
      • Using punctuation marks
      • Good word choice
      • Parallel construction
      • Effective paraphrasing
      • Sentence formation
      • Using pronouns effectively
      • Using articles correctly
      • Active vs. passive voice
      • First vs. third person
      • Proofreading tips
    • Journal Guidelines
      • Style guides
      • Manuscript preparation guidelines
      • Manuscript submission guidelines
      • Instructions for authors
      • Cover letter for journals
      • Journal templates
    • Manuscripts & Grants
      • All about plagiarism
      • Research titles
      • Manuscript sections
      • Meaningful impact statements
      • Literature review tips
      • Impactful academic biographies
      • Drafting case reports
      • Drafting grant proposals
      • Manuscript drafting tips
      • Writing review articles
    • Figures & Tables
      • Image editing tools
      • Artwork guidelines
      • Data visualization tips
      • Image manipulation
      • Graphical abstracts
    • Reference Management
      • Citations and references
      • Reference management tools
  • Publishing Research
    • Selecting Journals
      • Journal selection guidelines
      • Journal finder tools
      • Avoiding predatory journals
      • Predatory publishers
      • Selecting appropriate journals
      • Open Access Journal Finder (OAJF)
      • Journal quality and impact
      • Publishing in reputed journals
      • Types of open access
    • Submitting Manuscripts
      • Pre-submission inquiry
      • Avoiding plagiarism
      • Ethical issues
      • Identifying predatory journals
      • Common manuscript errors
      • Writing and publishing tools
      • Thesis publication
    • Understanding Reviews
      • Handling manuscript rejections
      • Impact of peer review
      • Peer review reports
      • Resources for peer reviewers
      • Pre- and post-publication review
      • Peer reviewers
      • Suggesting reviewers
      • Single- vs. double-blind
      • Open peer review
      • Types of peer review
    • Understanding Ethics
      • Contributor vs. co-author
      • Honorary & ghost authorships
      • Ethics & misconduct
      • Importance of research ethics
      • More on Creative Commons
      • Copyright infringement
      • GLP vs. GCP vs. GMP
      • Conflict of interest
      • Retractions
    • listen-podcast-on-academic-research-promotion-by-enago
  • Promoting Research
    • Using online media
      • Social media guide
      • Scholarly digital profile
      • Tips for promotion
      • Networking & sharing
      • Useful social platforms
      • Useful YouTube channels
    • Using social networks
      • Networking basics
      • Networking opportunities
      • Online groups
      • Marketing yourself
      • Professional networks
      • Social media
    • live-webinars-on-academic-publication-by-enago
    • free-ebooks-on-productive-academic-research-by-enago
  • Career Corner
    • PhDs & Postdocs
      • Why PhD?
      • Tips for PhD students
      • Earn while you learn
      • Research & grant proposals
      • Student–advisor relationship
      • Academic jobs
      • Research data management
      • Symposium-based presentations
      • Thesis vs. dissertation
      • Artificial intelligence
    • Product & Service Reviews
      • Designing graphical abstracts
      • Citation management
      • Search engine for researchers
      • Online citation generators
      • Keyword research tools
      • Designing figures & images
      • Electronic lab notebooks
      • Digital tools for researchers
    • Ask a Question!
      • Manuscript preparation
      • Manuscript submission
      • Journal selection
      • Open access publishing
      • Publishing ethics
      • Technical/peer review
      • Promoting published research
    • Enago Academy Creatives
      • SmartShorts
      • AcadFuns
      • PubToons
      • ResearchBriefs
      • QuoteDoctors
    • qa-forum-for-publication-success-by-enago
  • Industry News
    • Publishing News
      • Artificial intelligence
      • Horizon 2020
      • Big data
      • Journal citation reports
      • Nobel Prize
      • ResearchGate vs. publishers
      • Stephen Hawking
      • Predatory conferences
      • Journal impact factor
      • Open access
    • Expert Interviews
      • SciCrunch and RRIDs
      • Understanding the peer review process
      • Who are journal editors?
      • Journal editorial processes
    • listen-podcast-on-academic-research-promotion-by-enago
  • Get Published
    • journal-selection
    • journal-selection
    • journal-selection
    • journal-selection
    • journal-selection
  • Author Hub
    • Free Webinars
      • Getting Your Manuscript Edited by Professional Editors: Why is it Beneficial?
      • Getting Indexed in International Citation Databases
      • How to Survive Peer Review in Social Sciences and Humanities?
      • How to Effectively Promote Your Research
      • How to Assign Authorship & Contributorship
    • Book Reviews
      • Fulfilling the Trust: 50 Years of Shaping Muslim Religious Life in Singapore
      • Economics of Natural Disasters
      • Encyclopedia Of Thermal Packaging, Set 3: Thermal Packaging Applications (A 3-volume Set)
      • Introduction to Solid State Physics
      • Theology and Science: From Genesis to Astrobiology
    • Podcasts
      • An Editor-in-Chief Shares His Insights on ‘Avoiding Ethical Issues in Academic Publishing’
      • An Editor-in-Chief’s Advice on ‘How to Avoid Desk Rejections of Your Manuscript’
    • Workshops and Seminars
      • Enago’s Author Workshop at Yonsei University for Korean Researchers
      • Author Outreach Program by Enago: A Big Hit amongst Latin American Academics and Research Professionals
    • Enago Researcher Hub
      • Experience the wide-ranging power of technology with faster & convenient next-gen tools that enhance your writing and publication chances.
  • Subscribe Now
Enago Academy

Should rating of top reviewers be made available on journal websites?

Last updated Feb 8, 2019
2.90K viewsDecember 31, 2019Journal Selection
0
Anonymous22 September 18, 2018 0 Comments

Add a Comment

1 Answer

  • Active
  • Voted
  • Newest
  • Oldest
0
Enago Academy472 Posted September 20, 2018 0 Comments

Peer review process forms a crucial part in the publishing journey. Generally single-blind and double-blind peer review processes are used by journals. The identity of reviewers is never disclosed during both single-blind and double-blind peer reviews. This practice is consistently similar across most reputed journals like Nature, PLOS, Science, or Cell. Peer reviewers are mostly experienced members of the publishing industry. Currently, there is no such rating available for peer reviewers. In fact, some industry experts believe that peer reviewers may feel pressurized to share a relatively milder or biased feedback if they know that the manuscript authors may come to learn about their identity during or after the review process. In some cases, reviewer comments may turn out to be too harsh on the authors. Therefore disclosing their identity may help in reducing this practice among reviewers. However, a few other experts tend to believe that this may in fact bring in more transparency and accountability in the overall process. In summary, rapid access to peer reviewer ratings comes with its own set of pros and cons. Till date, no foolproof solution is available. Nevertheless, the peer review process itself should never be bypassed, regardless of whether the identities become public or not.

To know more about the peer review process, please check Enago Learn’ course on peer review process. To get your manuscript reviewed by experts, you can also avail Enago’ Peer Review services and increase your chances of manuscript acceptance.

Add a Comment
You are viewing 1 out of 1 answers, click here to view all answers.
Write your answer.
Register or Login
Trinka banner
Content Types
  • PhDs & Postdocs206
  • Old Webinars120
  • Webinar Mobile App74
  • News & Events58
  • Product & Service Reviews41
  • Infographics40
  • Workshops & Seminars38
  • Chinese18
  • Japanese15
  • Global Korea Webinars15
More resources
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
  • Webinars
  • EBooks
  • Checklists
  • Infographics
  • Q&A
  • Research Guide
  • Researcher Hub

Reporting Research

  • Language & Grammar
  • Journal Guidelines
  • Manuscripts & Grants
  • Reference Management
  • Figures & Tables

Publishing Research

  • Selecting Journals
  • Submitting Manuscripts
  • Understanding Reviews
  • Understanding Ethics

Important Links

  • PhDs & Postdocs
  • Product & Service Reviews
  • Ask a Question!

OUR SERVICES

  • English Editing Services
  • Copy Editing Services
  • Substantive Editing Services
  • Publication Support Services
  • Proofreading Services

About Us

  • Contact Us
  • Guest Contributor
  • About Enago Academy

GLOBAL ENAGO

Creative Commons License

Enago Academy offers comprehensive and up-to-date resources for researchers, publishers, editors, and students to learn and share their experience about research and publishing. Enago Academy also conducts workshops primarily for ESL authors, early-stage researchers, and graduate students. Our advanced workshop modules cater to the needs of researchers who want to know more about the issues pertinent to successful publication. Read More

Copyright © 2021 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Contact Us

[i]
[i]
[i]
[i]